Welcome to Nicky’s Pizzeria
At Nicky’s Pizzeria, our story is one of passion for authentic pizza and community connection. Nestled in Lexington, SC, we blend Southern hospitality with New York-style pizza, offering a warm atmosphere where friends and families can gather. Each dish is crafted from high-quality ingredients, including our signature pepperoni twists and gourmet pizzas with fresh toppings. Vegan and vegetarian options abound, ensuring everyone finds something to love. Our cozy outdoor seating invites you to enjoy your meal under the sky, while our inviting décor and attentive service make every visit special. Join us for a slice, and discover why we’ve become a local favorite!
-
102 E Main St Lexington, SC 29072 United States Hotline: (803) 490-0048
Welcome to Nicky’s Pizzeria, a gem nestled in the heart of Lexington, SC. At 102 E Main St, this vibrant restaurant embodies the essence of casual dining with an impressive array of pizza options that promise to delight any palate. Known for its warm Southern hospitality, Nicky’s Pizzeria is not just a place to eat but a hub where pizza lovers gather to indulge in their favorite slices.
Celebrated for its New York-inspired thin crust, Nicky’s offers a delightful selection that ranges from classic favorites like pepperoni and cheese to inventive toppings such as jalapeños and feta. Each pizza is made with meticulous attention to detail, ensuring that every bite is a perfect blend of flavors. According to patrons, the crust has an ideal balance of fluffy and crispy, making it irresistible, especially when paired with their house-made marinara.
- Location: 102 E Main St, Lexington, SC 29072
- Contact: (803) 490-0048
- Dining Options: Dine-in, takeout, and delivery available
What sets Nicky’s apart is their extensive menu designed to cater to various dietary preferences. With a multitude of vegan and vegetarian options, every guest can find something delightful to savor. Whether you’re stopping by for a quick slice during a busy day or settling in for a cozy dinner with family, Nicky’s Pizzeria provides a welcoming atmosphere complete with outdoor seating and heated areas to ensure a comfortable experience.
The restaurant buzzes with energy during its Happy Hour specials, where both beer and wine complement the food perfectly. As you enjoy your visit, indulge in starters like Garlic Cheese Bread or Fried Calamari, which set the tone for the main event—the pizza!
Guests rave about the attentiveness of the staff, emphasizing the personable service that enhances their dining experience. As echoed in reviews, the friendly atmosphere combined with top-notch food makes Nicky’s Pizzeria a must-visit for both locals and newcomers alike. From those seeking a laid-back dinner to families looking for a fun night out, Nicky’s caters to all, even your furry friends, with a dog-friendly policy.
All in all, Nicky’s Pizzeria stands as a testament to delicious pizza and exceptional service. Whether you’re craving a classic slice or eager to explore creative toppings, this restaurant invites you to find your favorite dish and become part of their growing community of pizza enthusiasts. Make your reservation today, and embark on your delicious journey at Nicky’s Pizzeria.
Great place!!! Pizza is amazing. Having the crust for breakfast. Had a great time and the owners, staff were full on southern hospitality. Only reason not five stars...watch your bar tab. Saw few tabs where an extra drink was added. Aside from that, highly recommend. If you're craving pizza you will not be disappointed.
We got pizza by the slice with drinks and sat outside in the fresh air. Molto bene!
Pizza was great...but I got a side of ketchup with my salad instead of the vinegarette I requested!
such a beautiful and comforting place to dine in on a rainy night. great location, seriously wonderful service. she was attentive the entire time and super sweet. food was exactly what i pictured and have been craving. it was delicious. i love that i live 3 minutes away to my new favorite place to eat. salad took less than 10 minutes, sub and pizza took about 15 minutes. so fast, so friendly, just overall a wonderful experience
We are visiting town and were walking by and went in on a whim. It was a Monday afternoon and there were a few people in there. It's a nice place. We wanted a single slice and a beer. The owner was there and a new kid and neither knew anything really about the beer. A woman sitting at a table chimed in and helped us (owners wife I assume). We got our pints and ordered a two topping slice and sat outside. The pizza was good. The crust seemed NY. Lacked sauce. They did an excellent job with toppings and my mushrooms were fresh, not canned.
My husband and I officially moved to South Carolina two days ago, and after a long day of moving, we decided to try Nicky's Pizzeria. We asked around for a laid-back place with good food and drinks, and we were pointed to this place. I don't eat meat, so I ordered half jalapeños/feta, and my husband ordered half pepperoni mushroom. The pizza did not disappoint; it was delicious. I was a little skeptical at first, as I'm used to my favorite places in the Northern VA/DC area. I also got the house salad with no olives and the red wine vinaigrette; it was good. My husband ordered the chicken wings extra crispy, and he thought they were okay, but he agreed the pizza was great. The owner and the servers were very personable; we told her it was our first day in town, and she recommended so many spots to try.
I have really missed Nicky's Pizza. Whe I found out that the location in 5 points closed, I literally cried because they were my favorite go-to place for NY thin crust style pizza. But I happened to be in Lexington and saw the name, so I went inside and asked if they were the same place. And they were. Straight up, I hugged the server, I was so happy!! So of course I had to order a few pieces "by the slice". The Sicilian is a deep crust pizza. I got it with sausage. The dough is just so fluffy but also crispy and flavorful, it begs for a bowl of extra sauce for dipping. But for me it was just a bit too much dough. I don't eat alot of bread so this is strictly a personal preference and not a slight on their ability to make awesome pizza. The other slice was a "Grandma slice" with shaved meatballs and OMG ! This was just so awesome. The crust wasn't quite as thin as Thin crust, but it easily definitely hand tossed. Oh so good! The place is bigger than the 5 points location with excellent natural light and they do serve beer and wine. They also have salads and pasta dishes if you're not in the mood for pizza.